Comparison

Timemator vs Toggl: Which Is Better for a Mac Freelancer in 2026?

Updated October 2026 · by Jerry Liu, Dayflow's founder

Timemator is the better pick for most solo Mac freelancers. A $39 one-time Mac license covers billable rates, revenue and rule-based auto-tracking, and keeps data on your device. Toggl wins if you also work on Windows or Android, share hours with a client or team, or want a free plan. Dayflow, our app, fits only if you want an automatic record rather than billing.

Timemator is a Mac app you buy once, and it starts and stops timers by itself based on the app, file or project you have open. Toggl (formerly Toggl Track) is a cloud service you subscribe to, built around timers you start yourself and around sharing hours with clients and teams on any platform. We also cover Toggl for Mac on its own page.

Disclosure: Dayflow, which shows up below as a third option, is our product. The method here is a comparison of each vendor’s own documentation as checked on 2026-10-04, with Dayflow’s facts reviewed against version 2.2.0 on 2026-09-06.

Quick comparison

ToolBest forHow it tracksPricePlatforms
TimematorSolo freelancers on Apple devices who bill by the hourAuto-tracking rules by app, file or project, plus a manual timer and activity timeline on Mac$39 one-time for Mac (2 devices); iOS app $7.99 one-timeMac, iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch
TogglFreelancers who work across platforms or inside client and agency teamsManual and real-time timers, timesheets, calendar integrations; background tracking and timeline in the desktop appFree for up to 3 users; Starter $9 per user per month billed annually or $12 monthly; Premium $16 annually or $24 monthly; Enterprise: contact vendorWeb, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android, browser extensions
Dayflow (ours)Keeping an automatic, readable record of your workdayRecords the screen at one frame every 10 seconds; AI writes a timeline$0 (MIT licensed); optional Pro at $20 a monthmacOS 14 or later

Key takeaways

What does Timemator do better than Toggl?

It is a purchase, not a subscription. Timemator for Mac is a $39 one-time payment covering 2 devices. If you want it on your iPhone or iPad, the iOS app is a separate $7.99 one-time payment. It is also offered through Setapp, if you already pay for that bundle. For a freelancer watching fixed costs, a one-time price is easy to justify against a single billable hour.

Billable hours are in the base product. The vendor lists billable hours with hourly rates and revenue among Timemator’s strengths. There is only one Mac plan, so you are not choosing a tier to get rates. Toggl puts billable rates behind its paid plans.

Its automatic tracking is rule-based and task-specific. You tell Timemator that a given app, file or project belongs to a given task, and it starts and stops the timer when that thing is open. For a designer whose client work lives in named project files, or a developer whose repos map neatly to clients, this can remove most of the start-stop routine. It also has a traditional manual timer for calls and offline work, and an activity timeline on the Mac.

Your data stays on your device. The vendor states that private data stays on the device, with iCloud sync across your devices and automatic backups. Nothing about your hours needs to sit on a third-party time tracking server.

Apple Watch and iOS coverage. If you start timers from your wrist or phone when you step away from the desk, Timemator has apps for iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch.

CSV out for invoicing. Timemator supports CSV import and export, which the vendor positions for invoicing. You take the export into whatever you already use to bill clients.

The vendor itself positions Timemator for freelancers and professionals such as designers, developers and filmmakers, which lines up with the job in the title.

What does Toggl do better than Timemator?

It works everywhere you do. Toggl has apps for web, Mac, Windows, iOS and Android, plus browser extensions. If you own a Windows machine for one client’s software, or you track from an Android phone, Toggl covers it and Timemator does not.

There is a real free plan. Toggl’s Free plan is described as free forever for up to 3 users, with timers, focus mode, calendar integrations, tasks and boards. If you only need to know how long things take, not bill for them, you can stay at $0. Timemator has no free tier, only a 30-day trial.

It is built for working with other people. Toggl lists billable rates and team reports, project planning with timelines, tasks and capacity management, and on Premium, timesheet approvals and profitability reports. If you subcontract for an agency that already runs its hours in Toggl, or you bring in a second freelancer, you are in the same system as everyone else.

Integrations. Calendar integrations are on the free plan. Jira and Asana integrations are on Premium. If a client manages your work in either tool, that link can save copying task names around.

AI features. Toggl lists Toggl AI for natural-language questions about workspace data and admin tasks, an MCP server, and an AI Task Creator. Timemator lists no AI features.

A clear privacy line on monitoring. Toggl states it does not take screenshots or record keystrokes. If a client asks what your tracker captures, that sentence is easy to forward.

Cloud access. Because Toggl is a web service, your hours are reachable from any browser and sync across web, desktop and mobile. For some freelancers that is a strength; for others it is the reason to pick Timemator.

One naming note: Toggl now presents itself as “Toggl”, combining time tracking with planning, and toggl.com/track redirects there. The vendor describes Toggl Track and Toggl Plan as legacy products still available to existing users.

Head-to-head table

CapabilityTimematorTogglDayflow (ours)
Automatic captureRules start and stop timers by app, file or project on Mac; activity timeline on MacBackground tracking and timeline listed for the desktop app; primarily timers and manual entryScreen recorded at one frame every 10 seconds; AI writes the timeline
Manual timersYesYes, manual and real-time timers plus timesheetsNone listed; recording runs in the background
Billable rates and invoicingBillable hours with rates and revenue; CSV export for invoicingBillable rates on paid plans; for invoicing, see Toggl’s pricing pageNo billable rates, no invoices
Team reportsNone listedYes; approvals and profitability reports on PremiumNo
Website blockingNone listedNone listed (free plan lists a focus mode)No
AI featuresNone listedToggl AI, MCP server, AI Task CreatorAI-written timeline via a local model, your own provider or Dayflow Pro
Data locationOn your device, optional iCloud sync and backupsCloud, synced across appsRecordings and timeline on your Mac; analysis local, or sent to your provider or Dayflow Pro
Free tier and trialNo free tier; 30-day trialFree forever for up to 3 users; 30-day trial on paid plansFree app at $0
PlatformsMac, iPhone, iPad, Apple WatchWeb, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android, browser extensionsmacOS 14 or later
Open sourceNoNoYes, MIT license

Pricing compared

PlanPriceBilling
Timemator for Mac$39One-time payment, 2 devices
Timemator for iOS$7.99One-time payment
Toggl Free$0Free for up to 3 users
Toggl Starter$9 per user per month / $12 per user per monthBilled annually / billed monthly
Toggl Premium$16 per user per month / $24 per user per monthBilled annually / billed monthly
Toggl EnterpriseContact vendorSee the vendor’s pricing page
Dayflow$0Free, MIT licensed
Dayflow Pro$20 per monthMonthly

What one freelancer actually pays. The job here is a Mac freelancer who bills by the hour, so billable rates are the requirement. With Timemator, that is $39 once for the Mac app, plus a separate $7.99 one-time payment only if you also want the iOS app. With Toggl, the cheapest plan with billable rates is Starter: $108 a year billed annually ($9 x 12), or $144 a year billed monthly ($12 x 12). Over three years that is $324 or $432 for Toggl Starter against a single $39 payment for Timemator on the Mac. If you need Toggl’s approvals or profitability reports, Premium is $192 a year billed annually or $288 billed monthly.

If you do not bill hourly and only want to see where time goes, Toggl Free at $0 is the cheapest option that keeps timers. Dayflow is also $0, and Dayflow Pro is $20 a month ($240 over 12 months) if you want Dayflow to handle the cloud AI analysis instead of running a model yourself. Our real hourly rate calculator helps put any of these subscriptions next to what an hour of your time is actually worth.

When should a freelancer choose Timemator?

For the mechanics of turning tracked time into an invoice on a Mac, our guide on how to track billable hours on a Mac walks through the steps whichever tracker you pick.

When should a freelancer choose Toggl?

If you are weighing Toggl against another popular Mac option, see Timing vs Toggl, and for the wider field of Mac time trackers, our roundup of the best time tracker for Mac covers more options side by side.

Where do Timemator and Toggl both fall short?

Both tools answer “how many hours went to which client”. Neither is built to answer “what did I actually do on Tuesday afternoon”.

Toggl’s own positioning is primarily timer and manual entry rather than a full automatic record, so a forgotten timer is a gap you reconstruct from memory. Timemator’s rules help, but they only catch the apps, files and projects you have written rules for. A research session in a browser, a client call that ran long, or an afternoon of small fixes across five repos can slip between rules or land on the wrong task. When a client questions a line item, or you need to write a weekly update, you are working from durations, not from a record of the work.

This is the gap Dayflow covers. It records the screen at one frame every 10 seconds, and AI turns that into a readable timeline of the day. Recordings and the timeline are stored on your Mac. The analysis can run fully on-device through a local model in Ollama or LM Studio, go to a cloud provider you configure, or go through Dayflow Pro, which under the privacy policy deletes screenshots after processing. The details are on our local and cloud processing page. You can export a date range as Markdown from Settings, which is handy for building a timesheet without manual entry or for answering a client who asks what a block of hours contained.

What Dayflow does not do is billing. It has no billable rates, no invoices, no team reports and no payroll approvals. So for a freelancer, the realistic setup is Timemator or Toggl for the hours and the invoice, with Dayflow next to it as the record. AI summaries can also miss or misread work, so check the timeline before you share it.

When is Dayflow the wrong pick?

Be honest with yourself about which job you are hiring a tool for.

The bottom line

For a freelancer who works only on Apple devices and bills by the hour, Timemator is the better fit. It costs $39 once for the Mac, includes billable hours with rates and revenue, tracks automatically through rules, and keeps your data on your device.

Pick Toggl instead if your work touches Windows, Android or a browser on another machine, if a client or agency already lives in Toggl, or if you want to start on a free plan before you bill. Budget at least $108 a year for Starter once you need billable rates.

If your real problem is not billing but remembering what filled the hours, add Dayflow alongside either one. It will not replace your invoice tool, and it is not trying to.

Frequently asked questions

Is Timemator a one-time purchase or a subscription?

According to Timemator's own site, Timemator for Mac is a $39 one-time payment that covers 2 devices, and Timemator for iOS is a separate $7.99 one-time payment. It is also available through Setapp. There is no free tier, but there is a 30-day trial, so you can set up auto-tracking rules and check the billable reports before you pay.

Does the free Toggl plan include billable rates?

No. Toggl's free plan is described as free forever for up to 3 users and includes timers, focus mode, calendar integrations, tasks and boards. Billable rates require a paid plan. For a freelancer who bills by the hour, the cheapest plan that fits is Starter at $9 per user per month billed annually, or $12 billed monthly.

Does Toggl work on Windows and Android?

Yes. Toggl lists apps for web, Mac, Windows, iOS and Android, plus browser extensions, and data syncs across all of them through its cloud service. Timemator runs only on Apple platforms: Mac, iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch. If any part of your work happens on a Windows PC or an Android phone, Toggl is the only one of the two that covers it.

Does Timemator track time automatically?

Yes, through rules. Timemator's auto-tracking rules start and stop timers based on the app, file or project you have open on your Mac. It also has a traditional manual timer and an activity timeline on the Mac. The quality of the automatic tracking depends on how well your rules match the way you actually work, so expect to tune them in the first weeks.

Where does Timemator store my data compared with Toggl?

Timemator states that private data stays on your device, with optional iCloud sync across devices and automatic backups. Toggl is a cloud web service, and its data syncs across the web, desktop and mobile apps. Toggl also states that it does not take screenshots or record keystrokes. Choose based on whether you want your hours local or reachable from any browser.

Does Toggl have AI features?

Toggl lists Toggl AI for natural-language questions about workspace data and admin tasks, an MCP server, and an AI Task Creator. Timemator lists no AI features. Dayflow uses AI differently: it writes a timeline of your day from periodic screenshots, using a local model, your own provider or Dayflow Pro. None of these AI features creates invoices.

Can Dayflow replace Timemator or Toggl for billing clients?

No, and this is where another tool clearly beats Dayflow. Dayflow does not provide invoices, billable rates, payroll approvals or team reports. If you bill by the hour, Timemator handles billable hours, rates and revenue for a one-time price, and Toggl handles billable rates on its paid plans. Dayflow is better used next to one of them, as a record of what the hours contained.

Which is cheaper over three years, Timemator or Toggl?

On the listed prices, Timemator for Mac costs $39 once, with the iOS app a separate $7.99 one-time purchase. Toggl Starter, the cheapest plan with billable rates, costs $108 a year billed annually, which is $324 over three years, or $432 over three years billed monthly. Toggl Free costs nothing but lacks billable rates. Check each vendor's page for current prices before buying.

Is Toggl Track still available?

Toggl now presents its product as Toggl, combining time tracking with planning, and toggl.com/track redirects to toggl.com. The vendor describes Toggl Track and Toggl Plan as legacy products still available to existing users. New sign-ups see the combined Toggl plans: Free, Starter, Premium and Enterprise, with Enterprise priced by contacting the vendor.

See where your day actually went

Dayflow is $0 and open source. Full recordings stay on your Mac, with local AI available for on-device analysis.

Download for MacOS macOS 14+ · MIT licensed · no account required