Comparison
Timing is the strongest pick if you want automatic Mac tracking with billing reports, from $9 a month billed annually. Dayflow (ours) is the free, open-source choice for a hands-off record of your day written by AI. Timemator suits a one-time $39 purchase with rule-based tracking, and Toggl wins if your team needs a free cross-platform timer.
If you keep your Mac’s menu bar full of small utilities, you probably want time tracking to behave the same way. It should always be running and rarely opened, and it should be quick to check when someone asks what you did on Tuesday. This ranking is for people on a Mac who want a record of their working hours without managing a timer window all day. The job is simple to state and hard to do well. The tool has to capture time with as little effort as possible, then give back something you can read, bill from or report on.
One honest note before the list. The product facts used for this article do not describe a menu bar item for any of these apps, Dayflow included, so nothing below claims one. Instead, each tool is judged on what a menu bar user cares about most: how much attention capture costs you. Dayflow is our product. It ranks second because it scores well on capture effort and price. It does not win on two criteria. On billing and invoicing, Timing is stronger (Timing vs Dayflow). On platforms beyond the Mac, Toggl (formerly Toggl Track) is far ahead (Toggl for Mac).
| Tool | Best for | How it tracks | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Timing | Automatic tracking plus billable-hour reports | Records apps, websites and documents automatically | Professional from $9/month billed annually, or $11/month billed monthly |
| Dayflow | A free, hands-off record of the day | Screen recordings turned into an AI-written timeline | $0, optional Pro at $20/month |
| Timemator | Rule-based auto-timers at a one-time price | Rules start and stop timers by app, file or project | $39 one-time (2 devices) |
| Daily | Timesheets without timers | Asks what you’re doing at intervals | Business: €39,99/year or €7,99/month per license, excl. VAT |
Best for billing: Timing. It tracks on its own and adds billing status and report rounding. Professional is $9 per month billed annually or $11 billed monthly, and there is a 30-day trial with no credit card.
Best free: Dayflow. It costs $0 under the MIT license and writes your day into a timeline without timers. Pro is optional at $20 a month if you want Dayflow to manage cloud analysis.
Best one-time purchase: Timemator. It costs $39 once for the Mac (2 devices) and gives you rule-based automatic timers and billable rates.
Best for teams: Toggl. The Free plan covers up to 3 users. Starter is $9 per user per month billed annually or $12 billed monthly, and it runs on Windows, Android and the web as well as the Mac.
Best for Apple Watch and location clock-in: Tyme. It has geofence clock in and out plus expense and mileage tracking. It costs $4.99 a month per user ($59.99 annual payment) or $6.99 a month billed monthly.
Best cheap timer: Hours TimeLord (formerly Hours Time Tracking). The Forever Free plan is $0, and Personal is $9.99 a year.
Best for answering instead of timing: Daily. It asks what you’re working on and builds the timesheet. The business license is €39,99 per year or €7,99 per month per license, excluding VAT.
A tool that sits at the top of the screen should cost almost no attention, so capture effort carries the most weight.
These tools were compared from each vendor’s own pricing and product pages as of 2026-10-04 (Dayflow’s facts were reviewed against version 2.2.0). No benchmark was run, and the scores are judgments.
Timing is a Mac-only automatic tracker built around billable-hour records. It captures time on its own across apps, websites and documents, down to specific URLs and Mail threads. It also lists manual entries, iOS activity import and call tracking. For someone who wants tracking to run quietly, that is the core appeal. You don’t start anything, and the record is detailed enough to assign to projects later. AI activity summaries, AI suggestions for time entries and an MCP integration come on all plans. The vendor states tracked times stay on your Mac unless you opt into sync. Billing status tracking, report rounding and GrandTotal invoicing integration (plan dependent) make it the strongest pick here for client work.
Professional is $9 per month billed annually or $11 billed monthly. Expert is $11 billed annually or $14 billed monthly. Connect is $16 per user per month billed annually or $20 billed monthly. The 30-day trial needs no credit card, and prices may vary by region or tax. The limits: there is no free tier, it is Mac only, and Professional covers one Mac with limited web app access.
Pick it if you bill clients by the hour and want the record to build itself.
Dayflow is our free, open-source Mac app that records your screen and has AI write the day into a readable timeline. Capture needs no timers, rules or prompts. Full screen recordings and the local timeline are stored on your Mac.
Analysis runs one of three ways. Local AI through Ollama or LM Studio keeps screenshot analysis on-device. Your own cloud provider processes selected screenshots under its own terms. Dayflow Pro manages cloud analysis. Under the privacy policy, Pro deletes screenshots after processing and may retain Activity Data for sync (how processing works). What you get back reads like a written account of the day rather than a list of app durations. You can export a date range as Markdown from Settings → Export.
The app is $0 under the MIT license, with an optional Pro plan at $20 a month (plans). It needs macOS 14 or later. The limits matter: Dayflow has no invoices, payroll approvals, team reports or website blocking. AI summaries can also miss or misinterpret work, so check them before sharing.
Pick it if you want to remember what you did without tracking anything by hand.
Timemator is a Mac app with iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch companions that turns rules into automatic timers. You set auto-tracking rules so a timer starts and stops based on the app, file or project you have open. A manual timer and an activity timeline are also available on the Mac. That middle ground suits someone who wants tracking mostly automatic but tied to named tasks from the start. Billable hours, hourly rates and revenue are built in, and CSV import and export cover invoicing in another tool. The vendor states private data stays on your device, with iCloud sync across devices and automatic backups.
Pricing is the draw: $39 one-time for the Mac (2 devices) and $7.99 one-time for iOS, with a 30-day trial. It is also available through Setapp. The limits: it runs on Apple platforms only, no AI features are listed, and the Mac and iOS apps are bought separately. Rules also take some setup before they pay off.
Pick it if you want automatic, task-based tracking and prefer paying once over a subscription.
Daily is a Mac tracker that replaces timers with a question. It periodically asks what you are doing and builds a timesheet from your answers. When you know you’ll be heads-down, you can apply an activity silently for a set duration. For someone who wants a tracker that appears briefly and then gets out of the way, that pattern fits, though it still needs a reply each time. Daily, weekly and monthly timesheets export cleanly. A Web API, Zapier and AppleScript let you send hours elsewhere. Data is kept on the Mac with optional iCloud sync and local backups.
The business license costs €39,99 per year or €7,99 per month per license, excluding VAT. Individual licenses are sold in the app through the Mac App Store, and the vendor site doesn’t print that price, so see the vendor’s pricing page. A trial is offered in the app, but its length isn’t stated. The limits: tracking is Mac only, the iOS app is for viewing and editing, and it relies on prompts rather than capturing apps or windows.
Pick it if you report hours to someone and want timesheets without timers.
Toggl is a cross-platform time tracking and planning service with apps for web, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android and browsers. Tracking is mainly manual and real-time timers, timesheets and calendar integrations. The vendor also lists automated background tracking and a timeline in the desktop app, and states it does not take screenshots or record keystrokes. Its strength is everything around the timer. Billable rates, team reports, project planning and capacity management are included. Timesheet approvals, profitability reports and the Jira and Asana integrations are on Premium. Toggl AI answers natural-language questions about workspace data, and there is an MCP server and an AI Task Creator. Data lives in the cloud and syncs across apps.
The Free plan covers up to 3 users. Starter is $9 per user per month billed annually or $12 billed monthly. Premium is $16 billed annually or $24 billed monthly. For Enterprise, contact the vendor. Paid plans have a 30-day trial. The limits: it is primarily timer and manual entry, and billable rates need a paid plan.
Pick it if your team spans Mac and Windows or needs shared reports.
Tyme is a timer-based tracker for Mac, iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch, with a web login in beta. You start and stop timers from the app, from shortcuts or from your wrist. Geofences can clock you in and out by location and record breaks automatically. That makes it useful if your work moves between an office, a studio and client sites. Team mode adds admin and member roles. Expense and mileage tracking and invoicing plugins such as GrandTotal, Lexware and sevdesk cover the billing side. The vendor says plans stay in sync across all your devices but doesn’t describe the sync backend. A Tyme MCP Server connects AI assistants, but no built-in AI features are described.
Pricing is $4.99 a month per user ($59.99 annual payment) or $6.99 a month per user billed monthly, with a 14-day trial. The limits: there’s no free tier and no automatic app or window capture listed. If you forget to start a timer, the time isn’t recorded.
Pick it if you live on Apple Watch or want location-based clock in and out.
Hours TimeLord is a one-tap timer app for iPhone, Mac and Android, with TimeLord Web on the Pro plan. You switch between timers for clients, projects and activities, and the day shows up on a visual timeline with tags and notes. For a light setup it’s the cheapest paid option here. Forever Free includes the visual timeline, 5 timers, summary reports and widgets. Personal is $9.99 a year, Pro is $49 a year and adds invoicing and bill rates, and Teams is $199 a year for 5 users. Pro and Teams have a 14-day trial. The Mac App Store listing shows slightly different in-app prices, so check there before buying. It requires macOS 11.0 or later.
Where data is stored is not stated on the pages checked, so see the vendor’s pricing page. The limits: it has no automatic app or website tracking, and full reporting and PDF or CSV export need a paid plan. The marketing site also looks stale, with a footer reading 2022. The App Store listing does show version 1.5.2 dated Aug 14.
Pick it if you want cheap, simple timers on an older Mac.
| Tool | Price | Automatic capture | AI summaries | Where data lives | Open source | Platforms |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Timing | From $9/month billed annually ($11 billed monthly) | Yes, apps, websites, documents | Yes, AI activity summaries | Local, optional sync | No | Mac |
| Dayflow | $0, Pro $20/month | Yes, screen recordings | Yes, AI-written timeline | Recordings and timeline on your Mac, analysis local or cloud by mode | Yes (MIT) | Mac (macOS 14+) |
| Timemator | $39 one-time (Mac), $7.99 one-time (iOS) | Rule-based auto-timers | None listed | On device, iCloud sync | No | Mac, iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch |
| Daily | €39,99/year or €7,99/month per business license, excl. VAT | No, prompt-based | None listed | On the Mac, optional iCloud sync | No | Mac, iOS (companion) |
| Toggl | Free (up to 3 users), Starter from $9/user/month billed annually | Mostly timers, background tracking listed for desktop | Toggl AI for workspace questions | Cloud | No | Web, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android, browser extensions |
| Tyme | $4.99/month per user ($59.99 annual payment) | No, timers and geofences | No built-in AI described | Cloud sync, backend not described | No | Mac, iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch, Web (beta) |
| Hours TimeLord | Free, Personal $9.99/year | No | None | Not stated, see the vendor’s pricing page | No | iPhone, Mac, Android, Web (Pro) |
What people usually want from a menu bar tracker is low friction. They want it always available, quick to glance at, and never a window they have to remember to open. Where the icon sits matters less than how often the tool interrupts you. A timer you have to start from the menu bar is still a timer you will forget at 3pm.
So it helps to split the field by what each tool asks of you. Timing and Dayflow ask nothing during the day; they capture in the background. Timemator asks for setup up front, then mostly runs itself. Daily asks a short question at intervals. Toggl, Tyme and Hours TimeLord ask you to start and switch timers, which is fine if you like explicit control and costly if you don’t.
If you’re weighing every time tracker for Mac, not just the low-effort ones, the broader ranking covers more categories. Before choosing, try the where does my week go calculator. It gives you a rough sense of which hours you’re actually trying to account for.
Three approaches avoid the start button, and each has a different cost.
Automatic capture (Timing, Dayflow) records what happens on screen and sorts it out later. The cost is review time. Timing gives you activity you assign to projects. Dayflow gives you a written timeline that AI can get wrong, so you read it before relying on it. The guide to automatic time tracking on Mac goes deeper on this approach.
Rule-based timers (Timemator) start and stop based on the app, file or project in front of you. The cost is setup. Rules have to match how you work, and work that happens outside matched apps needs a manual timer.
Prompts (Daily) ask you what you’re doing. The cost is a small interruption each time, though you can silence it for a set duration.
If timers have never stuck for you, time tracking without timers covers why and what to try instead.
You need invoices or billable rates. Dayflow doesn’t provide invoices or payroll approvals. Timing is the better choice, with billing status, report rounding and GrandTotal integration. Timemator is cheaper if you want to pay once. For a walkthrough, see how to track billable hours on Mac.
Your team needs shared reports. Dayflow has no team reports. Toggl has team reports and timesheet approvals (Premium), and its Free plan covers up to 3 users.
You use Windows or Android. Dayflow is Mac only. Toggl covers Windows and Android, and Hours TimeLord covers Android.
You’re on a Mac older than macOS 14. Dayflow won’t run there. Hours TimeLord’s App Store listing requires macOS 11.0 or later.
You want time logged by location or from your wrist. Tyme has geofence clock in and out and an Apple Watch app.
You don’t want AI involved at all. Timemator lists no AI features and keeps data on the device.
You want website blocking. Dayflow doesn’t block sites, and none of the tools here list blocking either. You’ll need a separate blocker.
| Tool | Plan | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Dayflow | Free | $0 (MIT license) |
| Dayflow | Pro | $20 a month |
| Timing | Professional | $9 per month billed annually, or $11 per month billed monthly |
| Timing | Expert | $11 per month billed annually, or $14 per month billed monthly |
| Timing | Connect | $16 per user per month billed annually, or $20 per user per month billed monthly |
| Timemator | Timemator for Mac | $39 one-time payment (2 devices) |
| Timemator | Timemator for iOS | $7.99 one-time payment |
| Daily | Business license | €39,99 per year or €7,99 per month, per license, excluding VAT |
| Daily | Individual (in-app, Mac App Store) | Not printed, see the vendor’s pricing page |
| Toggl | Free | $0, free for a limited number of users (up to 3) |
| Toggl | Starter | $9 per user per month billed annually, or $12 per user per month billed monthly |
| Toggl | Premium | $16 per user per month billed annually, or $24 per user per month billed monthly |
| Toggl | Enterprise | Contact vendor |
| Tyme | Annual | $4.99 / Month per user ($59.99 annual payment) |
| Tyme | Monthly | $6.99 / Month per user (monthly payment) |
| Hours TimeLord | Forever Free | $0 |
| Hours TimeLord | Personal | $9.99 / year |
| Hours TimeLord | Pro | $49 / year |
| Hours TimeLord | Teams | $199 / year (5 Users) |
If you just want to know where your hours went, Dayflow at $0 with Local AI costs nothing beyond your own hardware, though local models need resources to run. If you bill from one Mac and dislike subscriptions, Timemator at $39 once is the cheapest sensible paid setup. Hours TimeLord Personal at $9.99 a year covers plain timers.
If you bill clients and want tracking that runs on its own, pick Timing. If you want a free, readable record of your day with no timers, pick Dayflow, and plan to read its summaries before sharing them. If you want automatic timers and a one-time price, pick Timemator. If your team works across Mac and Windows, pick Toggl.
Dayflow is free at $0 under the MIT license, Toggl has a Free plan for up to 3 users, and Hours TimeLord has a Forever Free plan with 5 timers. The vendor details checked for this article don't confirm a menu bar item for any of them, so open the app or its listing to see where it sits. Dayflow needs macOS 14 or later.
Timing and Dayflow both capture time without timers. Timing records apps, websites and documents, and Dayflow records the screen and has AI write a timeline. Timemator starts and stops timers automatically from rules you set. Daily skips timers too, but it asks what you're doing at intervals, so it still needs a short reply each time.
Yes. Timing has billing status tracking, customizable reports with rounding and GrandTotal invoicing integration depending on plan, with Professional at $9 per month billed annually or $11 billed monthly. Dayflow does not provide invoices or billable rates. If your main goal is turning tracked hours into invoices, Timing is the better pick, and Timemator is the cheaper one-time alternative at $39.
No. Timing has no free tier. It offers a 30-day trial with no credit card required. After that, Professional costs $9 per month billed annually or $11 billed monthly, Expert $11 billed annually or $14 billed monthly, and Connect $16 per user per month billed annually or $20 billed monthly. Prices were read with a US locale and may vary by region or tax.
Yes. Timemator for Mac is a $39 one-time payment covering 2 devices, and Timemator for iOS is a separate $7.99 one-time payment. There's a 30-day trial, and the app is also available through Setapp. It has rule-based auto-tracking, hourly rates and revenue for billable hours, but no AI features are listed on the vendor's site.
It's now presented as Toggl, combining time tracking with planning, and toggl.com/track redirects to toggl.com. The vendor describes Toggl Track and Toggl Plan as legacy products still available to existing users. Pricing starts with a Free plan for up to 3 users, then Starter at $9 per user per month billed annually or $12 billed monthly.
The product is now called Hours TimeLord, and the old site redirects to hourstimelord.com. The Mac App Store listing shows version 1.5.2 dated Aug 14 and requires macOS 11.0 or later. The website lists Forever Free at $0, Personal at $9.99 a year, Pro at $49 a year and Teams at $199 a year for 5 users. In-app prices on the App Store differ slightly.
No. Daily periodically asks what you're doing and builds a timesheet from your answers, rather than capturing apps or windows. You can apply an activity silently for a set duration to skip prompts. Data stays on the Mac with optional iCloud sync. The business license is €39,99 per year or €7,99 per month per license, excluding VAT.
Timing says tracked times never leave your Mac unless you opt into sync. Timemator keeps private data on the device with iCloud sync, and Daily keeps data on the Mac with optional iCloud sync. Dayflow stores recordings and the timeline locally. With Local AI, analysis stays on-device, while your own provider or Dayflow Pro processes selected screenshots off-device. Toggl and Tyme sync through the cloud.
Toggl is the only tool here with a Windows app, alongside web, Mac, iOS, Android and browser extensions. Hours TimeLord covers iPhone, Mac and Android, with TimeLord Web on the Pro plan. Timing, Daily and Dayflow are Mac only for tracking. Tyme and Timemator stay on Apple platforms, and Tyme's web login is in beta.
Dayflow is $0 and open source. Full recordings stay on your Mac, with local AI available for on-device analysis.
Download for MacOS macOS 14+ · MIT licensed · no account required